Stuckey & Co. Blog

How to Win Large Accounts in Small Commercial with The Hartford

Written by Stuckey & Company | Feb 19, 2026 8:00:00 PM

During our recent webinar with The Hartford, we explored how independent agents can win larger premium accounts inside the Small Business segment — and why many producers underestimate what’s possible.

If you think small commercial means small premium, think again.

Expanded Thresholds = Larger Opportunity

The Hartford’s small business platform supports:

  • Workers’ Compensation up to $20M payroll (select classes)
  • Property values up to $40M per location
  • Up to $50M in sales for qualifying classes
  • Five- and six-figure premium accounts

These thresholds allow agents to keep accounts in small business instead of pushing them to middle market unnecessarily.

How to Pre-Qualify Like an Underwriter

Winning large accounts starts before submission.

Key steps discussed:

  1. Confirm appetite fit (class, sales, payroll).
  2. Identify target premium and competitive landscape.
  3. Submit 60–90 days prior to effective date.
  4. Provide full loss runs + supplemental apps.
  5. Tell the story of the risk (controls, safety, website review).

Strong pre-qualification reduces back-and-forth and speeds turnaround.

Use Credits Strategically

The Hartford allows:

  • Up to 40% discretionary credit (state-dependent)
  • Additional underwriting credit when justified
  • Paid-in-full discounts

When selling on value — not just price — transparency about target premium helps underwriting compete.

Payroll Billing: A Major Differentiator

Payroll billing:

  • Charges based on actual payroll
  • No deposit required
  • No minimum premium
  • Integrated with 1,000+ payroll companies
  • Reduces audit surprises

It’s often a deciding factor in competitive situations.

Claims & Risk Engineering Win Accounts Back

One real example shared:
A large surveying firm left for price — then returned because of claim handling quality.

The Hartford’s approach includes:

  • 7–10 day claim follow-ups
  • Nurse case management specialization
  • Risk engineering access through My Account portal
  • 24/7 digital self-service

Value matters.

Final Takeaway

Small commercial is not “small.”

With the right prequalification process, underwriting partnership, and strategic positioning, agents can confidently pursue larger premium opportunities.

If you’d like:
• The Countrywide Definitions document
• Access to Stuckey’s discovery tools
• Help prequalifying a risk

Reach out. We’re here to help you win.